DHS Proposes to End Deference to Prior Approvals on H-1B and Other I-129 Extensions

H-1B

If you are an H-1B worker or an employer who sponsors one, you have probably relied on a quiet assumption: once USCIS approves your petition, the next extension on the same job should be easier. A new proposal from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) could change that. Here is what is being proposed, who it affects, and what you can do now.

What Is “Deference” to Prior Approvals?

When USCIS reviews a Form I-129 petition involving the same parties and the same underlying facts as an earlier approval, the current rule tells officers to defer to that earlier decision. The exceptions are a material error, a material change, or new information that undermines the original approval. The regulation requires USCIS to defer to its prior eligibility determination in such cases.

In simple terms, if you are extending the same H-1B for the same employer, in the same role, USCIS should not reopen questions it already answered. DHS wrote this principle into 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5) in December 2024 as part of the H-1B modernization rule. Before that, it existed as USCIS policy guidance.

What Has DHS Proposed?

The proposed rule, titled “Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility,” was published on October 14, 2026, under docket number USCIS-2026-0529. It would delete 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5) and leave the paragraph

USCIS would also revise its guidance that requires officers to explain, and get supervisory approval for, a decision not to defer. Officers could still look at your earlier approval, but they would no longer be expected to start from it.

Who Would Be Affected?

The change would cover every classification filed on Form I-129. That includes H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, E and P petitions. DHS says H-1B petitions make up more than 75 percent of all I-129 filings, so H-1B workers would feel it the most. 

For Indian professionals the stakes are high. USCIS data shows that about 79 percent of roughly 258,000 approvals for continuing employment went to Indian-born workers. If you are an Indian national on an H-1B in the United States, or an employer with Indian talent on your team, this proposal deserves your attention.

Why Does DHS Want to End Deference?

DHS has put numbers behind its case. It estimates about 208,429 I-129 petitions a year, roughly 30 percent of all filings, are eligible for deference. It projects about 6,044 additional requests for evidence (RFEs) each year if the rule is finalized. DHS also reports a 64-day difference in processing time between petitions with and without an RFE. USCIS Deference to Prior Approvals May End: What the October 14 Proposal Means for H-1B, L-1, and O-1 Extensions +2

DHS considered keeping deference as a discretionary option, but chose not to propose it, saying it would create confusion.

Critics see it differently. Stuart Anderson of the National Foundation for American Policy argues that removing deference means USCIS will re-adjudicate facts it has already found to be true. 

What Would Change in Practice?

If finalized as proposed, a routine extension could be treated much like a fresh filing. You might see:

  • More RFEs. Documents you submitted years ago may be requested again, such as job duties, specialty occupation evidence, and employer-employee details.
  • Longer timelines. Every RFE adds response time and review time. For workers near the end of their authorized stay, that can be stressful.
  • Less predictability. An approval last time would no longer be a strong signal for the next filing.
  • Higher preparation costs. Employers may need to build every extension petition as if it were a first-time case.

What Would Not Change?

The eligibility requirements for each classification would not change. The proposal changes how USCIS reviews an extension, not the legal standard. A well-documented case that qualified before should still qualify. The risk is in documentation gaps and inconsistent adjudication, not a new test. 

Is This Rule in Effect Now?

No. This is only a proposal. The current deference regulation stays in effect unless and until DHS publishes a final rule and it takes effect. The public comment period has been running, with news reports in early November describing the window as closing. Final rules can differ from proposals, and DHS may revise the text or the timeline. Please check the Federal Register for the latest status. 

How Employers and H-1B Workers Can Prepare

You do not need to wait for a final rule to get ready. Sensible steps include:

  1. Build a complete evidence file now. Keep job descriptions, org charts, degree and credential evaluations, project records, pay records, and client letters in one place and up to date.
  2. File extensions early. Where the rules allow, file as soon as you are eligible so an RFE does not collide with your status expiry date.
  3. Keep roles and facts consistent. Make sure your LCA, petition, and actual duties line up. Inconsistencies invite scrutiny under any standard.
  4. Track status carefully. Maintain proof of lawful status, since adjudicators may look at it closely.
  5. Plan for contingencies. Workers close to their 6-year H-1B limit, or those with pending green card steps, should review their timelines with counsel.
  6. Consider commenting or monitoring. Employers and industry groups can follow the docket and see how comments shape the final rule.

Why Speak to an Immigration Attorney?

A proposal like this does not need panic, but it does reward preparation. Every extension strategy depends on your facts: your employer, your role, your time left in status, and your long-term plans. A short review now can prevent a costly RFE later.

At Orange Law, we help employers and professionals plan H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN and other I-129 filings, and respond to RFEs with strong, well-organized evidence. If you have an extension coming up in the next 12 months, we can review your file and suggest a plan.

Speak to Karan Joshi at Orange Law to discuss how this proposal could affect your case.

Final Thoughts

DHS’s proposal would remove a protection that many H-1B and I-129 petitioners have relied on for years. The rule is not final, and eligibility standards would stay the same. Even so, employers and workers should expect closer scrutiny of extensions and prepare their documentation early.

START YOUR CASE

Checkbox Items